PLATINUM VS WHITE GOLD?

It’s not just about platinum vs white gold or is platinum more valuable than white gold?! When choosing a piece of jewellery, be it a diamond engagement ring or a sapphire necklace, it is important to have some knowledge about all precious metals so you can make an informed choice. We have put together the following information which we sincerely hope makes you more confident when deciding which metal to choose. 

WHAT IS THE CHOICE?

To put it simply, with regards precious metals you have the option of platinum, gold, or palladium

PLATINUM

This is the elite of the white metals.  For indepth info please click platinum for wikipedia information.

Pros:

  • Heaviest
  • Rarest of the precious metals
  • Currently 2023 it is more keenly priced than 18ct white gold
  • Doesnt wear as much as the gold and silver so great for gemsetting
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Generally the strongest
  • Naturally bright white colour
  • Doesnt require plating

Cons:

  • Only available in white

gold

The chameleon precious metal!

Pros:

  • Available in different colours, mainly white, yellow and rose
  • Available in different carats (purity) so it can fit different budgets
  • Generally a hard metal so quite resistatnce to scratches
  • The yellow and rose gold varieties do not require plating

Cons:

  • White gold usually requires plating which wears (this is discussed below)
  • Depending on what the gold is mixed with and the purity, some golds can be softer in comparison to platinum for example.
  • Golds wear more than platinum and palladium.
  • White gold is currently (2023) higher priced than platinum

palladium

A recent rise to fame.

Pros:

  • Doesn’t wear as much as the gold and silver
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Generally a hard metal
  • Naturally bright white colour
  • Doesn’t require plating
  • More reasonable than platinum

Cons:

  • The metal is very light in comparison to platinum so you do not get a sense of substance with this metal
  • Only available in white

I want a white metal - which one should i choose? Platinum VS white gold VS palladium?

Our general recommendations would be Platinum, followed by 18ct white gold, and finally palladium. 9ct and 14ct white gold are available – in brief 14ct can be a great option cost wise and 9ct, due to its low gold content is more of a budget option.

WHAT IS RHODIUM PLATING?

Rhodium is a bright white metal, like platinum in its appearance, and is used to essentially ‘cover’ or plate white gold. The plating makes the white gold (which is usually slightly off-white or grey) appear “whiter” and also offers a slight increase in durability. However, this plating doesn’t last forever. In fact it’s advisable to have rhodium plated rings re-plated every 12 to 24 months to keep them looking new. Click Rhodium Plating for more info about plating in general including.

WHAT CARAT GOLD SHOULD I CHOOSE?

9ct, 14ct and 18ct are the main choices of carat available.  These numbers signify that they contain respectively 38%, 58% and 75% pure gold. At Andrew Geoghegan we generally only use 18ct golds within our pieces. We do this because the colours of the golds are strong in 18ct – so for example 18ct yellow has a rich yellow colour – but also we prefer to use as pure a metal as possible – in keeping with beautifully made jewellery. Our recommendation is to choose 18ct golds if possible but when budgets dont allow then you could consider 14ct or 9ct. For more indepth details about gold purity and caratage, the Gold Council have some excellent information – as you would expect!

WHAT COLOUR GOLD SHOULD I CHOOSE?

This is in the main down to personal preference but there are certain considerations that we would recommend. If the piece is going to be gem set then certain colour metals will work particularly well with certain gemstones. For example, chocolate coloured diamonds can look fantastic in rose gold however sapphires may not look as pleasing in this colour of gold.
We would advise to keep the metal choices the same on the finger – so for example if you have a platinum engagement ring, then you should go for a platinum wedding ring.

We hope the above information is of use to you in your dilemma of platinum or white gold. We are here to help you at every step of the way so please do not hesitate to ask for advice and help. To view the collection of designer engagement rings and see how we use platinum and white gold to incredible effect – click here.